A Record Quarter and a Falling Stock — What "Beating Estimates" Actually Measures
On October 8, Samsung Electronics reported the best quarter any Korean company has ever reported. Preliminary operating profit for July through September came to 107.4 trillion won, up 782.5% from a year earlier — the first time a company in Korea has cleared 100 trillion won of operating profit in a single quarter. Revenue was 195 trillion won. Both numbers topped the record the company had set only three months before. The profit figure also came in slightly above the consensus estimate — the average of analysts' forecasts, which FnGuide put at about 106 trillion won. That afternoon, Samsung's shares closed down 2.42%, at 268,500 won. A record, a beat, and a falling price, all on the same day. It looks like a contradiction. It is not, and the reason is worth understanding this week in particular, because the American earnings season is starting, and the same arithmetic is about to be applied to hundreds of companies at once. Here is the judgment I keep coming back to: an...